Celebrate flavor at its finest with this curated collection of nationally and internationally award-winning dairy delights. Featuring our artisan butter—proud medalist at the U.S. Championship Cheese Contest—and a selection of cheeses that have earned top honors on the U.S. and world stage, this gift is made for those who appreciate the best. Whether you're sending it as a thoughtful gesture or savoring it yourself, The Winning Spread delivers a winning taste in every bite.
Inside you’ll find:
Royal Guernsey Butter Trio, 24 oz., Columbus, WI, made from the milk of our own cows in Columbus, WI, this set includes all three of our butters: Salted, Sweet Cinnamon (a toast-lover’s dream), and our Signature Butter—a savory blend of roasted garlic, black pepper, and parsley that earned a Silver Medal at the 2025 U.S. Championship Cheese Contest.
Henning's Aged Cheddar Gouda Cheese, 16 oz., Kiel, WI, a Gold Medalist and Top 20 finisher at the 2024 World Cheese Championship is everything a cheese lover dreams of: bold, nutty, perfectly aged, with a crumbly yet creamy texture.
Hoard’s Dairyman Farm Creamery Sark Butterkase Cheese, 7 oz., Ft. Atkinson, WI, made with Guernsey milk, this Triple Cream Butterkäse is smooth, buttery, and a 2025 U.S. Championship Cheese Contest Gold Medal Winner. Perfect for melting or pairing with fruit and wine.
Prairie Junction Almond Toffee, 4 oz., East Troy, WI, a sweet finale made in small batches with milk chocolate and roasted almonds swirled into crisp, buttery toffee.
