The Easiest Thing to Bring to New Year’s

Award-winning farmstead butter, Wisconsin cheese and other giftable local favorites — just outside Columbus, Wisconsin.

Perfect for hosting, thank-you gifts, and New Year’s gatherings.

Featured on WMTV-15: Why We Built the Butter Barn

Local news visited our farm to share how we sell butter straight from our own cows. Our store is just steps away from the cows who produced the cream used in our butter.

What You’ll Find Inside the Butter Barn

  • Farmstead Butter

    Made in small batches with cream from our own cows.

  • Wisconsin Cheese

    Hand-selected Wisconsin cheeses that pair beautifully with our butter and make easy, crowd-pleasing gifts.

  • In-Store-Only Finds

    Seasonal items and in-store surprises you won’t find online.
Most visitors are in and out in under 10 minutes — and leave with gifts they feel great about.

Why People Love the Butter Barn

  • Award-winning farmstead butter – made with cream from our very own cows.
  • Perfect for gifting – everyone uses butter, and everyone loves good butter.
  • Real farmers, real cows – the cows are just steps from the shop.
  • Fast, easy holiday shopping – no crowds, no guessing, no mall fatigue.

If you’ve ever worried “Will people like this?” — butter is the gift that always gets used.

Plan Your Visit

We’re a small, on-farm shop — quick in, easy out, and worth the drive.

Holiday Hours (thru 12/30)

Saturdays & Sundays: 10 a.m. – 3 p.m.
Mondays & Tuesdays: 11 a.m. – 2 p.m.
Friday (12/26): 11 a.m. – 2 p.m.

Or by appointment: (608) 620-7676
If you’re trying to squeeze us in, give us a call — we do our best to accommodate.

Address
W11674 Duffy Road
Columbus, WI 53925

GPS may take you to our house — keep going about 0.2 miles and look for the little brown barn in front of the large dairy barn with the tan roof.

View map & directions

One stop. No crowds. Always useful.

Skip the mall. Support a local farm. Leave with gifts people actually love.

Visit the Butter Barn